Policy Recommendation: Treatment First Plus

Introduction

Substance use disorder (SUD) remains a pervasive social issue in the United States, contributing to rising incarceration rates, housing insecurity, and unemployment. Traditional punitive approaches, such as incarceration for relapse, fail to address the underlying factors driving addiction and recidivism. While initiatives like the "Treatment, Not Imprisonment" Bill have taken critical steps toward reframing relapse as a health issue, they fall short of providing the systemic support needed for long-term recovery. I recognized these gaps and developed Treatment First Plus—a comprehensive policy integrating wraparound services like transitional housing, job placement, and family counseling. Addressing individual and systemic barriers, Treatment First Plus promotes sustainable recovery, reduces recidivism, and ensures equitable access to resources for underserved populations.

​

Policy Goals

The primary goal of Treatment First Plus is to promote sustainable recovery and reduce recidivism for individuals with substance use disorder (SUD) by addressing both individual and systemic barriers. This policy recognizes SUD as a chronic health condition, moving beyond a punitive response to prioritize a holistic, evidence-based approach to treatment.

​

The specific objectives of Treatment First Plus include:

1. Providing immediate housing stability through transitional housing.

2. Ensuring economic independence via job placement and workforce training.

3. Supporting family reunification through counseling and family support services.

4. Expanding eligibility to include individuals at risk of relapse due to socioeconomic challenges, regardless of judicial involvement.

5. Establishing financial sustainability through dedicated funding mechanisms.
    

By operationalizing these goals, Treatment First Plus reduces systemic barriers contributing to relapse, fostering measurable improvements in stability, independence, and long-term recovery outcomes (Chapin, 2020, p. 226; NIDA, 2020).

​

Benefits and Services

Treatment First Plus provides a comprehensive package of wraparound services that directly address the root causes of SUD and relapse. These services include:
 

1. Transitional Housing

   • Provides safe, stable housing for individuals recovering from SUD.

   • Addresses housing insecurity, which often drives relapse and recidivism.

   • Research shows that housing-first models significantly improve recovery outcomes (SAMHSA, 2023; Pew Charitable Trusts, 2022).

2. Job Placement and Workforce Training

   • Offers vocational training, resume-building, and placement programs in stable employment sectors.

   • Reduces financial instability, which is a primary risk factor for relapse (NIDA, 2020).

   • Employers benefit from partnerships with treatment programs, creating a path to reintegration (National Alliance on Mental Illness [NAMI], 2022).

3. Family Counseling and Support Services

   • Facilitates family reunification and strengthens support networks.

   • Promotes family-centered recovery strategies to foster long-term stability.

4. Mental Health and Trauma Support

   • Offers counseling and mental health services tailored to individuals experiencing trauma and co-occurring disorders.

   • Research highlights that untreated trauma worsens relapse rates (SAMHSA, 2023; CDC, 2022).

These integrated services build a foundation for recovery, reduce stigma, and empower individuals to rebuild their lives with dignity and self-sufficiency.

​

Eligibility Rules

Unlike policies that restrict services to individuals under judicial oversight, Treatment First Plus ensures broad eligibility:

• Open to individuals at risk of relapse due to socioeconomic factors, such as housing insecurity or unemployment.

• Does not require involvement in the criminal justice system (e.g., probation, pretrial).

• Eliminates restrictive means tests that penalize individuals who achieve financial or housing stability.
   

By prioritizing equity, this expanded eligibility ensures that underserved populations—especially those excluded from justice-centered interventions—have access to critical resources (Chapin, 2020, p. 227; Pew Charitable Trusts, 2022).

​

Service Delivery Systems

Treatment First Plus creates Regional Community Hubs integrating treatment, housing, and workforce services. These hubs:

1. Coordinate Multi-Agency Partnerships

   • Align treatment providers, housing agencies, job placement organizations, and community-based services.

   • Streamline services to ensure individuals receive seamless support.

2. Leverage Community Assets

   • Use existing infrastructure, such as schools, health clinics, and nonprofit organizations, to deliver services locally.

   • Promote cultural responsiveness by hiring multilingual staff and providing tailored services.

3. Ensure Accessibility

   • Offer extended hours, telehealth services, and in-home visits to address logistical barriers like transportation and geographic isolation.

This decentralized, client-centered delivery model empowers individuals to choose services that meet their needs while addressing inequities in access (Chapin, 2020; SAMHSA, 2023).

​

Financing

Treatment First Plus employs a sustainable financing model to ensure long-term viability:

1. Earmarked Revenues

   • Allocates a percentage of alcohol and cannabis tax revenues to fund treatment and support services.

   • These taxes provide a consistent funding stream directly tied to the sources contributing to addiction (Pew Charitable Trusts, 2022).

2. Federal Grants

   • Secures federal funding through programs like HUD for transitional housing and the Workforce Innovation and Opportunity Act (WIOA) for job placement.

3. Cost Savings Reinvestment

   • Savings from reduced incarceration and judicial costs are reinvested into the program.

   • Studies demonstrate that treatment-focused approaches generate substantial cost savings compared to punitive systems (NIDA, 2020; SAMHSA, 2023).

This diversified approach ensures financial stability, scalability, and consistent service delivery without relying on volatile state budgets (Chapin, 2020, p. 228; CDC, 2022).

​

Recommendation: Treatment First Plus

Treatment First Plus is the superior policy because it:

• Addresses the root causes of relapse through housing, employment, and family support.

• Expand eligibility to include underserved populations, ensuring equity and access.

• Establishes sustainable funding to guarantee long-term implementation and scalability.

• Promotes measurable outcomes, including reduced recidivism, improved housing stability, and economic independence.
   

By tackling individual and systemic barriers, Treatment First Plus provides a comprehensive, evidence-based solution that empowers individuals to recover, thrive, and contribute to their communities.

​

References

• Chapin, R. K. (2020). Social policy for effective practice: A strengths approach (4th ed.). Routledge.

• Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (2022). Opioid overdose crisis statistics. Retrieved from https://www.cdc.gov/opioids

• National Alliance on Mental Illness. (2022). Employment and mental health. Retrieved from https://www.nami.org

• National Institute on Drug Abuse. (2020). Evidence-based treatment for substance use disorders. National Institutes of Health. Retrieved from https://www.drugabuse.gov

• Pew Charitable Trusts. (2022). Reducing recidivism through housing and workforce programs. Retrieved from https://www.pewtrusts.org

• Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration. (2023). Barriers to accessing treatment for substance use disorders. Retrieved from https://www.samhsa.gov

This version significantly expands the detail in each section, incorporates six references, and strengthens the rationale for Treatment First Plus. Let me know if you'd like further refinements or adjustments!